Is Born This Way really a gay anthem?

“‘Born This Way’, which is the title song, will completely get rid of Gloria Gaynor’s ‘I Will Survive’. This is the new ‘I Will Survive’. That was the gay anthem. This is the new gay anthem. Actually, it’s not a gay anthem – it can apply to anybody.” – Elton John

There was a lot of hype surrounding Lady Gaga’s single “Born This Way.” We’ve been hearing about it for months. I really dislike when people talk about songs before they’re available. It sets up an unrealistic expectation and people only do it to name drop. Okay Perez, we get it, you’re friends with Lady Gaga. Now go bedazzle an alpaca or something, just as long as I don’t have to watch.

I think if Elton John hadn’t come out and said as much, people would be responding differently, so let’s forget he ever talked about Born This Way, forget about all the hype leading up to its release, and get down to it.

Born This Way IS an anthem.

The lyrics, literal and cheesy, are meant to be so. Who here has ever been to a protest? You don’t mince your words, you get right to the point. This isn’t a song about lust or angst, it’s a song about being proud of who you are. Born This Way intentionally escapes the mold to make a point, hiding behind poetic tricks would have detracted from the message.

Of course there are those who say it’s a copy. A copy of Express Yourself, a copy of God Is A DJ; to be honest, I heard a lot of other songs too. Pop imitates pop. Every song sounds like some song before it. What separates a clone from something great is whether it does something new; whether it’s current (or ahead of it’s time), and relevant. Madonna and Pink are well established pop artists with a history of releasing empowering songs about individuality. Gaga channeled the vibes of her contemporaries to add to the story.

There’s one thing we can all agree upon- this song is divisive. For every person who falls in love with it and carries it with them there are going to be ten people who hate it. Gaga may be amongst the biggest stars in the world right now, but she still has a very young career. It takes cahones to release something like this. Leave any doubts that Gaga truly believes and cares about equality behind, this girl is more than a pop star, she’s an activist.

Share
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Is Born This Way really a gay anthem? | that.dork.jordan -- Topsy.com

  • http://twitter.com/caratweets Cara

    I haven't been able to listen yet, but I agree with everything you said. Pop is cyclical and everyone copies everyone. I'm tired of the comparisons, but it goes with the territory, I suppose. Very eager to hear the song! Good post, Boov.

  • http://twitter.com/beauvbrown Beau Brown

    Well put my friend!

  • oscarraymundo

    I agree and disagree :D

  • http://twitter.com/Lissi0903 Lissette Alvarez

    I completely agree with you!

  • Thain

    I'd say We Are The Champions is a far better gay anthem than I Will Survive ever was. Besides, the revised version of that song is actually very religious in nature.

    Anyway. Heard it, its ok. Too 80s sounding for my liking. Seems like she's trying to be the next Madonna, both in looks and music. I didn't care for the original all that much either TBH. Also the cynic in me has to question whether its so much that she's truly a supporter of equality, or simply pandering to her audience.

  • Jackie

    I wish she didn't use “chola descent” or “orient” in the song though – both phrases hold pretty determinative meanings and I don't agree with them.. Could've just used Hispanic or Asian, but I guess that doesn't rhyme…

Mobify empowers marketers and developers to create amazing mobile web experiences. Tap to learn more

Mobify